The 1999 comedy American Pie became a cultural phenomenon, bringing together a talented ensemble cast and creating unforgettable characters that fans still cherish today. Over two decades later, the cast has grown, evolved, and ventured into new careers. Let’s take a look at what the American Pie cast looks like now in 2024, compared to their breakout roles in the late ’90s.

Jason Biggs (Jim Levenstein)
Then: Jason Biggs became an instant household name for his portrayal of the awkward, loveable Jim Levenstein. His infamous pie scene is forever etched in movie history.
Now: Biggs continued his acting career post-American Pie, starring in series like Mad Love and Orange is the New Black. He also lent his voice to several animated projects and appeared in films like Barbershop 2 and The Hot Chick. As of 2024, he’s appeared in a few comedy shows and is active on social media, giving fans updates about his personal life.

Alyson Hannigan (Michelle Flaherty)
Then: Known for her role as the quirky, band-camp-loving Michelle, Alyson Hannigan’s iconic “This one time, at band camp…” line became legendary.
Now: Hannigan went on to star in How I Met Your Mother, where she played the lovable Lily Aldrin. She also appeared in Veronica Mars and voiced characters in animated series. In 2024, Hannigan is still very much a fan favorite and continues to work in both television and voice acting.

Chris Klein (Chris “Oz” Ostreicher)
Then: Chris Klein’s character, Oz, was the smooth-talking, loveable jock who grew throughout the film series, eventually finding love in a surprising way.
Now: Klein had a successful career post-American Pie, with notable roles in Election and Here on Earth. His more recent projects include recurring roles in TV series like The Flash and a continued presence in smaller film projects.

Seann William Scott (Steve Stifler)
Then: Seann William Scott’s portrayal of the loud and crude Stifler made him a breakout star. His over-the-top antics and memorable one-liners earned him a lasting place in comedy history.
Now: Scott transitioned into more serious roles but never abandoned his comedic roots. He starred in movies like Dude, Where’s My Car? and Goon and has appeared in a number of TV shows and films. In 2024, he’s still acting, with appearances in both comedy and action genres.

Tara Reid (Vicky Lathum)
Then: Tara Reid played Vicky, the girl-next-door who had a memorable relationship with Kevin (Thomas Ian Nicholas).
Now: Reid’s post-American Pie career saw a variety of roles, including Van Wilder and Sharknado. She faced ups and downs in her career but has remained a recognizable face in Hollywood. As of 2024, she’s been involved in reality television and occasionally pops up in films and shows.

Thomas Ian Nicholas (Kevin Myers)
Then: As Kevin, Thomas Ian Nicholas was the sweet, earnest high schooler who was just trying to find love and make memories with his friends.
Now: Nicholas stayed in the entertainment industry, starring in films like Rookie of the Year and The Last Best Summer. He’s also a musician and continues to release music, often performing at live events. In 2024, he still has a loyal fan following.

Eddie Kaye Thomas (Paul Finch)
Then: Eddie Kaye Thomas’s character, Finch, was the intellectual, who found unexpected romantic success in the American Pie universe.
Now: Thomas has had a solid TV career, starring in the hit show Scorpion and appearing in various film and television projects. In 2024, he continues to have a successful career in both comedy and drama.

Mena Suvari (Heather)
Then: Mena Suvari played Heather, Oz’s love interest in the first film. Her role helped launch her into Hollywood stardom.
Now: Suvari went on to star in several films, including American Beauty and Loser. She has appeared in both film and TV shows and, in 2024, remains active in her acting career, taking on more mature roles and continuing to connect with fans on social media.

American Pie may have made its mark on pop culture in the late ‘90s, but its cast has grown in exciting and varied directions. From comedy to drama, TV to film, the actors who once embodied high school antics have gone on to accomplish great things—though fans will always remember them best for their unforgettable roles in American Pie.